Variability in blood glucose readings is a problem for ALL diabetics. Humans, dogs and cats never have identical blood glucose readings and/or curves from day to day.
Stress is a factor to be considered; both humans and pets have some days which are more stressful than others. Diet can be another factor in variability, certainly for people and especially for pets who are not on one of the many diabetes prescription diet foods.
No matter how a person with diabetes may micromanage his or her blood glucose, he/she will never be successful at making today's readings exact "photocopies" of yesterday's.
Intervet states some fine reasons for variability at the link below. As you see, there are many different factors involved. When there's too much variance in them, though--marked differences in highs and lows--it's a signal that things need to be re-evaluated. More/less insulin, bad/weak insulin, changing insulins, etc.--all need to be considered if and when this occurs.
What needs to be realized is that insulins can be variable in two ways--in different patients (interpatient) and also in the individual patient (intrapatient). Variability is not solely an "insulin problem"; it can occur with ANY drugs or treatments.
The Novo Nordisk study at the link below shows how different insulins (in this case NPH, Lantus, and Levemir) can give different variabilities.
The 2002 German study linked below re: variability of insulins in humans gives some idea of the sort of problem it is for all those with diabetes. (It is unclear whether Levemir was part of this study; Lantus was available at the time and therefore can be considered to be part of it.) All insulins, have some degree of variability from patient to patient and for the same patient. The variability problem is not solved by the analogs, as they have the same variability problems as all of their non-analog counterparts.
It was believed that by changing the way insulin was administered (from injection to inhalation) might elminate some of the variability factors; this proved to be false. Further complicating the variability matter when looking at human studies is the fact that there are no applicable studies of the variability of injected insulins in persons with diabetes.
What is known on variability is that R/Neutral non-analog insulin varies less in "healthy subjects" (those without diabetes), than Intermediate-acting (NPH and mixes, Lente) and Long-acting (Ultralente). The study does not give head-to-head data regarding the analog insulin variability, but it does indicate that the analog insulins--both rapid-acting and long-acting, have the same variability issues. There is not yet a method to significantly reduce variability.
Absorption and the insulin depotEdit
The size of the Insulin depot influences variability, with smaller unit doses varying less than larger ones. Dr. Richard K. Bernstein, father of the modern Glucometer, also makes a valid case for this, as does Dr. Hanas.
Intervet also addresses the issue when stating that the dose per injection on a twice-daily regimen is less (then the large once-daily injection), which results in less hypoglycemia and better glucose control
Variability and needle lengthEdit
Some caregivers report difference in insulin absorption with different length needles. BD Diabetes explains that you should consult with your health care professional before using a short needle, and carefully monitor blood glucose when changing to a shorter needle.
People have found their blood glucose may not be well-controlled when switching to the shorter needles; this also has been the case with some dogs. Switching back to a longer needle solved the problem. You should consider experimenting with the different length needles as insulin absorption may vary.
Part of diabetic lifeEdit
It was once thought that when regulated, dogs who were fed the same meals on the same food and insulin schedule had very little day-to-day variability of their blood glucose. Dr. Fleeman and Rand investigated, and found that dogs and cats, like humans, can vary quite a bit.
- ↑ BD Diabetes-Insulins for Cats
- ↑ DiabetesNow UK-Page 4
- ↑ Caninsulin-Serial Blood Glucose Curves (Page 8)
- ↑ Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus & Use of Flexible Insulin Regimens-Hirsch-American Family Physician-1999
- ↑ Insulin Treatment-Individual Factors
- ↑ Comparison of Levemir (insulin detemir), NPH/Isophane Insulin & Lantus (insulin glargine)
- ↑ PubMed-Variability of Insulin Absorption and Insulin Action
- ↑ Pharmacokinetics of Insulin Following Intravenous & Subcutaneous Administration in Dogs-Biopharmaceutics & Drug Disposition-1986
- ↑ Absorption & Kinetics of Regular (Neutral) & NPH (Isophane) Insulin in the Normal Dog-Domestic Animal Endocrinology-1987
- ↑ Boulder Medical Center-Insulin-Dr. Higgins
- ↑ Dr. Bernstein--The Laws of Small Numbers-Part 2
- ↑ David Mendosa's Page on Dr. Richard K. Bernstein's Accomplishments
- ↑ Dr. Bernstein--The Laws of Small Numbers
- ↑ Insulin-Dependent Diabetes (Pages 10 & 11)
- ↑ Caninsulin-Starting Insulin Therapy in the Healthy Diabetic Patient (Page 4)
- ↑ BDdiabetes.com-Using Short Needles
- ↑ Diabetes Care-ADA Position Statement 2004
- ↑ JAVMA 2003 Evaluation of Day-to-Day Variability of Blood Glucose Curves in Diabetic Dogs
- ↑ Insulin Sensitivity Measures in Cats Exhibit High Variability-ACVIM 2006-Page 77, Abstract #221
- ↑ Columbia Animal Hospital-Diabetes in Cats
- ↑ Drs. Foster & Smith-Pet Education-Regulating & Monitoring a Diabetic Cat Using Insulin